Willow Cookie Co

Order our decorated sugar cookies and everything in between -

"Baking treasures that bring joy to every taste bud."

About Willow Cookie Co

A serene landscape with mountains, a lake, and clear blue skies reflecting tranquility and natural beauty.

Our Philosophy

At Willow Cookie Co , we believe in using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients to create delicious sugar cookies and visually stunning baked goods. We take pride in our attention to detail and strive to exceed our customers' expectations with every order.

A picturesque landscape featuring rolling hills, vibrant green fields, and a clear blue sky.

Our Heritage

Our family has been in the baking business for over 5 years, and we have brought our passion for baking to Willow Cookie Co. We continue to innovate and create new flavors and designs.

Indulge in Our Sweet Creations - A Photo Gallery of Willow Cookie Co

Don't just take our word for it!

Welcome to Willow Cookie Co

Indulge in our delicious, handcrafted treats made with the freshest ingredients. From cookies to cakes, we've got something to satisfy your sweet tooth. Visit us today!

Find out more

Meet the Baker

Hi! I’m Athena, I’m not a baker by passion - I actually fell in love with the decorating part first. I’m a completely self-taught baker and I love getting creative and trying new things, even if I’ve never done it before - I’m always up for the challenge, lol. I grew up watching my mom bake and I’m sure that influenced me more than I realized. She’s passed now but baking still feels like a special connection to her.

I really enjoy working with my community and I’m grateful to be able to sell my baked goods locally at a deli here in town.

Being a cookie maker is humbling because it connects you to others through shared joy- I do a little happy dance. I owe it all to God and the people who support me.

Thank you for being here - it truly means alot to me and my family.

Contact Us

Willow Cookie Co, LLC

Wantagh, New York 11793, United States

Hours

Open today

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Willow Cookie Co

About Willow Cookie Co

Our Philosophy

Our Heritage

Indulge in Our Sweet Creations - A Photo Gallery of Willow Cookie Co

Menu

Mini Baked Donuts - Box Of 25 - STARTS AT $30

Classic Cookies -$2.50 Each

Chocolate chip

Funfetti

Double Chocolate

Cupcakes - Regular Size $3.50 each

Red velvet

Vanilla Birthday

Chocolate/Cookies n' Cream

Vanilla/Chocolate Birthday

Chocolate/Cookie Dough

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Cookie Cakes- 11.5/12"round starts at $20

Classic Chocolate Chip

Triple Chocolate Chocolate Chip

Funfetti

Cookies & Bakes- Daily

Celebration Mini Cake bento box - Starts at $25

CUSTOM - Decorated Sugar Cookies

DYE FREE - CUSTOM DECORATED SUGAR COOKIES AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

Custom Edible Images - Photo - Text - Logo

Don't just take our word for it!

Welcome to Willow Cookie Co

Meet the Baker

Contact Us

Willow Cookie Co, LLC

Hours

Drop us a line!

Willow Cookie Co

About Willow Cookie Co

Our Philosophy

Our Heritage

Indulge in Our Sweet Creations - A Photo Gallery of Willow Cookie Co

Menu

Mini Baked Donuts - Box Of 25 - STARTS AT $30

Classic Cookies -$2.50 Each

Chocolate chip

Funfetti

Double Chocolate

Cupcakes - Regular Size $3.50 each

Red velvet

Vanilla Birthday

Chocolate/Cookies n' Cream

Vanilla/Chocolate Birthday

Chocolate/Cookie Dough

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Cookie Cakes- 11.5/12"round starts at $20

Classic Chocolate Chip

Triple Chocolate Chocolate Chip

Funfetti

Cookies & Bakes- Daily

Celebration Mini Cake bento box - Starts at $25

CUSTOM - Decorated Sugar Cookies

DYE FREE - CUSTOM DECORATED SUGAR COOKIES AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

Custom Edible Images - Photo - Text - Logo

Don't just take our word for it!

Welcome to Willow Cookie Co

Meet the Baker

Subscribe

Contact Us

Willow Cookie Co, LLC

Hours

Drop us a line!

Connect With Us

This website uses cookies.